For me, at least, the MEDIUM TAN seems like a much better match for my complexion than the ligher MEDIUM. This seems to be a better liquid foundation than L'Oreal Infallible Fresh Wear. I like ELF brands too.I think I will become COVERGIRL CLEAN FRESH SKIM MILK Foundation convert over L'Oreal. I used to always use L'Oreal Perfect Match in a N5 in Winter, and N6 in Summer. It seems that L'Oreal no longer makes this product even though it certainly was superior to the Infallible Fresh Wear. I could never find my shade of N5 or N6 in drug stores anymore. .. then eventually, I could not find any L'Oreal Perfect Match liquid foundation, or the cream compact foundation ANYWHERE anymore. I was very disappointed beause it was my favorite, and I always wore it. Covergirl Clean Fresh foundation will be taking the place of L'Oreal from now on. The Medium is an OK color for me in the Winter, and I have good thoughts about it too. Superior to the current L'Oreal Infallible which wears off quickly. I wish L'Oreal would bring back PERFECT MATCH Liquid and Cream versions because it was a much superior foundation make up compared to the current L'Oreal Infallible. I do prefer the two COVER GIRL liquid foundation make ups to what L'Oreal is putting out now with Infallible, which is watery junk.