My Maizie LOVED these treats! They're the perfect size for training. We've taught our Beagle many commands using these as a reward! Beagles are not the easiest dog to train as they are quite "busy" with the world around them. Without the promise of a treat, THIS treat, Maizie would prefer sniffing the world around her, birdwatching, or just running around like a madman! And the container is the best for storage. It keeps the treat "fresh" and is great for handling - - not too bulky. I would buy these again and again. The price is great as far as a training treat goes. The texture is soft but not too sofe ... It provides a crunch that Maizie seems to like. The smell, unlike some treats, is very pleasant. You can definitely smell the peanut butter. Other treats sometimes smell almost like ammonia, especially the "bacon-type" treats!I would most definitely recommend these to anyone looking for treats for their dog. And not just as a training aide! They're perfect for just a treat when you want to remind your fur-baby how much you love him/her!I wish I could give this more stars as a rating ... But I can't, so I'm gonna say 5 star, most definitely!